Public vs. Private Employment & Pay
MAY 11, 2010 | Policy Points by COMMONWEALTH FOUNDATION
Pennsylvania's private sector lost 113,600 jobs while state and local governments added 40,200 positions between 2000 and 2009, according to the Bureau of Labor Statistics.
At the same time, public-sector wages exceed those for comparable positions in the private sector.
According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, Pennsylvania's public-sector employees are, on average, better paid than private-sector workers in similar occupations in the same geographic area, even before the public sector's more generous health-care and pension benefits are included.
| Public and Private Sector Mean Hourly Wages, by Occupation | ||||
| Management | ||||
| Pennsylvania | Private Sector | Public Sector (State & Local) |
Percent Difference | Report Date |
| Philadelphia Region | $37.03 | $37.08 | 0.14% | Jan-09 |
| York Area | $29.63 | $33.01 | 11.41% | Oct-08 |
| Pittsburgh Area | $29.84 | $37.02 | 24.06% | Mar-09 |
| Reading Area | $27.14 | $34.83 | 28.33% | Jan-09 |
| Johnstown Area | $22.88 | $26.00 | 13.64% | Jun-09 |
| Service | ||||
| Pennsylvania | Private Sector | Public Sector (State & Local) |
Percent Difference | Report Date |
| Philadelphia Region | $11.56 | $23.37 | 102.16% | Jan-09 |
| York Area | $8.72 | $16.25 | 86.35% | Oct-08 |
| Pittsburgh Area | $9.71 | $19.16 | 97.32% | Mar-09 |
| Reading Area | $10.20 | $15.79 | 54.80% | Jan-09 |
| Johnstown Area | $9.48 | $18.53 | 95.46% | Jun-09 |
| Sales and Office | ||||
| Pennsylvania | Private Sector | Public Sector (State & Local) | Percent Difference | Report Date |
| Philadelphia Region | $16.83 | $19.77 | 17.47% | Jan-09 |
| York Area | $14.08 | $15.05 | 6.89% | Oct-08 |
| Pittsburgh Area | $14.46 | $17.42 | 20.47% | Mar-09 |
| Reading Area | $15.72 | $17.57 | 11.77% | Jan-09 |
| Johnstown Area | $13.62 | $12.34 | -9.40% | Jun-09 |
| Natural Resources, Construction and Maintenance | ||||
| Pennsylvania | Private Sector | Public Sector (State & Local) |
Percent Difference | Report Date |
| Philadelphia Region | $22.18 | $22.35 | 0.77% | Jan-09 |
| York Area | $18.98 | NA | Oct-08 | |
| Pittsburgh Area | $18.59 | $17.86 | -3.93% | Mar-09 |
| Reading Area | $17.23 | $19.01 | 10.33% | Jan-09 |
| Johnstown Area | $19.10 | NA | Jun-09 | |
| Production, Transportation and Material | ||||
| Pennsylvania | Private Sector | Public Sector (State & Local) |
Percent Difference | Report Date |
| Philadelphia Region | $16.72 | $19.86 | 18.78% | Jan-09 |
| York Area | $14.94 | NA | Oct-08 | |
| Pittsburgh Area | $17.57 | $16.21 | -7.74% | Mar-09 |
| Reading Area | $15.65 | NA | Jan-09 | |
| Johnstown Area | $14.56 | NA | Jun-09 | |
| Source: www.bls.gov/ncs/ocs/compub.htm#PA | ||||
# # #
For more on Public Employee Pensions and Benefits visit www.CommonwealthFoundation.org
The Commonwealth Foundation (www.CommonwealthFoundation.org) is an independent, non-profit research and educational institute.
To download the full PDF version, please click here
Media contact:
media@commonwealthfoundation.org
(O) 717-671-1901
Who are We?
The Commonwealth Foundation is Pennsylvania's free-market think tank. The Commonwealth Foundation crafts free-market policies, convinces Pennsylvanians of their benefits, and counters attacks on liberty.
Pension Crisis Facts: Are 401(k)s Enough?
May 24
Pennsylvania needs pension reform that provides state workers with a sustainable retirement system that’s fair to new workers, existing employees and taxpayers. What are our options? The current system is a defined benefit pension plan that guarantees a government income for life. Switching to ...