Pennsylvania Education Spending
JUNE 29, 2010 | Policy Points by COMMONWEALTH FOUNDATION
Pennsylvania faces a projected General Fund shortfall of over $1 billion. Gov. Rendell proposed a $29 billion budget for FY 2010-11 that increases taxes, and is demanding a $350 million increase in basic education subsidies to school districts. This is the seventh in a series of fact sheets on the Pennsylvania state budget.
Pennsylvania cannot spend its way to educational success
- K-12 public education spending has skyrocketed in Pennsylvania:
- Pennsylvania's education spending increased from $4 billion in 1980 to over $25 billion in 2009 - a 133% increase in per-pupil spending, from $6,171 to $14,420 (in 2010 dollars).
- School construction and debt spending has doubled in just 10 years. Prevailing wage laws increase the cost of construction by 20% or more; repealing this mandate would save $400 million annually in construction costs.
Public school staffing has increased while enrollment has declined
|Pennsylvania Public School Enrollment and Staff|
|(includes public charter schools)|
|Source: PA Department of Education|
- Since 2000, enrollment has declined by 26,960 while schools have hired 32,937 more staff members.
- Most of these new employees pay dues to the PSEA labor union, which runs one of the largest political action committees in the state and heavily funded Gov. Rendell's campaigns.
K-12 public education performance has stagnated
- Despite these spending and staff increases, performance on the NAEP exam has changed little.
- Academic studies have found little or no correlation between student achievement and class size, teacher salaries, or per-pupil expenditures.
- Pennsylvania ranks a dismal 43rd in the nation in combined SAT score, and scores have not improved over time.
Public schools have $2.7 billion in reserves
- Reserve funds have increased over $1 billion since 1996-1997 to $2.7 billion
- School district fund reserves are almost 8 times the amount of Gov. Rendell's proposed $354 million increase in state subsidies.
School choice saves taxpayer money
The $75 million Educational Improvement Tax Credit (EITC) was reduced in last years' budget deal, while subsidies for school districts rose by four times the cost of the entire EITC. Another cut to the EITC is scheduled, while school districts are in line for an increase of over $300 million.
- The average EITC Scholarship is $1,100, compared with the average school district spending of over $14,000 per-pupil.
- If the EITC were to be cut and scholarship opportunities reduced, many students would be forced back into high-cost public schools, resulting in higher property taxes.
- The EITC saves taxpayers almost $500 million per year by allowing children to attend better or safer schools at a lower cost to taxpayers.
# # #
Who are We?
The Commonwealth Foundation is Pennsylvania's free-market think tank. The Commonwealth Foundation transforms free-market ideas into public policies so all Pennsylvanians can flourish.