An Arizona-like Immigration Law for PA?
Following Arizona's recent enactment of a law intended to enforce federal illegal immigration laws, Pennsylvania State Representative Daryl Metcalfe has introduced similar legislation. The law would force employers to use e-Verify to check immigration status on new employees and would allow police to detain those who cannot provide proof of legal status (e.g. a photo ID, like a driver's license) if they are stopped for a primary offense (like speeding).
Here is some thoughtful discussion of the Arizona law:
- Heather MacDonald of the Manhattan Institute offers praises Arizona, arguing that the new law may prove effective, and criticism of it for racial profiling is overblown.
- Colin Hanna takes issue with some of the rhetoric about the Arizona law, specifically that police will be able to arrest anyone with brown skin (rather than only those committing a primary offense).
- Cato's Dan Griswold argues for immigration reform to allow more workers to enter legally.
- In a 2009 paper, the Heritage Foundation outlines recommendations for state and local governments to address the illegal immigration issue, as well as calling for the federal government to ease legal immigration.
RELATED : JOBS & ECONOMY
Who are We?
The Commonwealth Foundation is Pennsylvania's free-market think tank. The Commonwealth Foundation crafts free-market policies, convinces Pennsylvanians of their benefits, and counters attacks on liberty.